• Name: Byron Rakitzis
  Location: US - United States of America (United States)
  
  
• Name: Sean Dorward
  Location: US - United States of America (United States)

To build:

    make all

The authors provided another version of this program. See the alternate version section below.

Bugs and (Mis)features:

The current status of this entry is:

STATUS: INABIAF - please DO NOT fix

For more detailed information see 1990/tbr in bugs.html.

A note about the fixes of this entry in 2023:

In 2023 it was noticed that in some systems like macOS there was confusing output due to a warning at runtime that was interspersed with the output of the program. For instance it would show:

    ./tbr
    $ warning: this program uses gets(), which is unsafe.

which kind of hid the prompt. Thus the entry was changed to use fgets(3) which is referred to later in this file.

Also exit(3) returns void but the entry was using it in a binary expression so this entry would not compile in modern systems. This fix is also referred to below, in the alternate version section.

To use:

    ./tbr
    $ enter some shell commands

NOTE: globs do not work with this entry. Why?

NOTE: exit does not work and neither does logout. To exit try sending ctrl-d or ctrl-c (or kill it from another terminal :-) ). But why does it not work with just exit or logout? Hint: see the authors’ remarks.

Try:

    ./tbr
    $ ls -l tbr tbr.c

    # notice how the following does not work:
    ls tbr*

    # try figuring out how this entry works in an editor:
    vi tbr.c

    # then figure out how to exit vi :-)

What happens if you try using cd - to return to previous directory? What about cd with no args?

The authors include a section called BUGS that, because they were documented, are not considered bugs as such in the context of the contest.

Alternate code:

The authors supplied us with a slightly smaller unformatted version of the program:

    #define D ,close(
    char*c,q[512],m[256],*v[99],**u,*i[3];int f[2],p;main(){for(m[m[60]=m[62]=
    32]=m[*m=124[m]=9]=6;e(-8),gets(1+(c=q))||(exit(0),0);r(0,0))for(;*++c;);}
    r(t,o){*i=i[2]=0;for(u=v+98;m[*--c]^9;m[*c]&32?i[*c&2]=
    *u,u-v^98&&++u:3)if(!m[*c]){for(*++c=0;!m[*--c];);*--u=
    ++c;}u-v^98?strcmp(*u,"cd")?*c?pipe(f),o=f[1]:1,(p=fork())?e(p),o?
    r(o,0)D o)D*f):4,wait(0):(o?dup2(*f,0)D*f)D o):*i?1 D
    0),e(open(*i,0)):5,t?dup2(t,1)D t):i[2]?9 D
    1),e(creat(i[2],438)):2,e(execvp(*u,u))):e(chdir(u[1])*2):6;}
    e(x){x<0?write(2,"?\n$ "-x/4,2),x+1||(exit(1),0):5;}

This is the alternate source except that it has the exit() returns void fix as well as the gets(3) to fgets(3) fix applied to it to make it functionally equivalent like the authors intended. The above code is their original alternate code.

Alternate build:

    make alt

Alternate use:

    ./tbr.alt

Judges’ remarks:

This program touches on a well known Unix utility, the 6th edition Bourne Shell (/bin/sh), whose original source was considered to be extremely obfuscated by many people (although Steve Bourne might disagree). Did you know that the Bourne Shell source was a major inspiration for the formation of the IOCCC back in 1984?

Authors’ remarks:

This program is a rudimentary shell. It does I/O redirection, pipes and cd. It flags errors on failed chdir(), open(), creat(), execvp(), fork() and a few syntax errors.

This program is obfuscated in a few notable ways: apart from the layout (an unformatted (but crunched) version is included for people who want to put this through cb) it makes clever use of a write() statement, so that the same statement can be used to print errors and the prompt. By calling the error function with the value -8, the pointer offset in the expression "?\n$ "-x/4 goes from 0 to 2. Presto! A prompt. For errors with numbers smaller than -4 (i.e., UNIX system calls) a question mark is printed.

The error value of chdir() is doubled so that we don’t exit from the parent shell on a chdir() error (since e() exits on -1 errors only). All other system call failures exit since they are from sub-shells.

Recursion is sneakily employed to avoid a second call to fork(), and the line is parsed in a fairly bizarre fashion: backwards. The heart of the program, that is, the part which performs all fork()s, exec()s, open()s, etc. is ONE C STATEMENT.

The meta-values array is initialized in a bizarre fashion, and the subsequent checks for the '<' and '>' are performed in a single statement using a mask, since you know that '>'&2 is 0, whereas '<'&2 is 2. Other such micro-obfuscations abound.

Finally, it is notable that the code was hacked for minimality. If you look at the compressed version, you will be hard-pressed to eliminate more than a few characters (we can’t see how to make it any smaller!). 550 characters is pretty lean for a shell that does this much.

BUGS

The syntax of the shell has not been fully explored, but if you try to redirect in the same direction more than once, only one redirection is performed. This is a “feature” of the way the line is parsed; a pointer to the stack of arguments is assigned and an argument is stolen every time a > or < is encountered. The shell flags an error if no arguments are on the stack. Thus, for example:

    cat > foo > bar

cats to foo, since it was pushed last, but

    cat > > foo bar

cats to bar, since bar was pushed under foo (remember we’re parsing right-left).

Depending on your flavor of Unix, cd without an argument will either produce an error or just do nothing.

There is just one error message, the question mark, but hey, that’s all ed(1) does too.

Primary files

• tbr.c - entry source code
• Makefile - entry Makefile
• tbr.alt.c - alternate source code
• tbr.orig.c - original source code

Secondary files

• 1990_tbr.tar.bz2 - download entry tarball
• README.md - markdown source for this web page
• .entry.json - entry summary and manifest in JSON
• .gitignore - list of files that should not be committed under git
• .path - directory path from top level directory
• index.html - this web page

---

Jump to: top